Chargeback fraud poses a significant threat to merchants, costing businesses an estimated $38 billion in 2023. This growing problem affects companies of all sizes and types, potentially causing serious harm to their financial health and reputation.
Merchants should be concerned about chargeback fraud not only because of the immediate financial losses but also due to the long-term consequences, such as increased processing fees and the risk of losing their merchant accounts.
Understanding and preventing chargeback fraud is crucial for maintaining a healthy business and protecting profits in an increasingly digital marketplace.
What is a Chargeback?
A chargeback is the reversal of a credit card charge initiated by a customer's bank or payment processor, usually resulting from a customer dispute. It was originally designed as a consumer protection mechanism against unauthorized transactions, billing errors, or undelivered goods and services.
When a chargeback occurs, the disputed amount is refunded to the customer, and the merchant loses the sale along with associated fees. Chargebacks differ from regular refunds in that they are forced transactions initiated by the financial institution on behalf of the customer. This process bypasses the merchant's standard refund procedures and can have more severe consequences.
For subscription-based businesses, chargebacks can be particularly damaging, as they not only affect the disputed transaction but can also impact future recurring revenue. The chargeback system, while necessary for consumer protection, has unfortunately become a target for abuse. Some customers exploit this system to obtain goods or services without payment, leading to what is known as chargeback fraud.
How Does the Chargeback Process Work?
The chargeback process typically involves several steps and multiple parties. Understanding this process is crucial for merchants to effectively manage and prevent chargebacks. Here's a general overview of how it works:
The customer initiates a dispute: The process begins when a cardholder contacts their issuing bank to dispute a charge on their statement.
The issuing bank reviews the claim: The bank assesses the validity of the customer's claim and decides whether to proceed with the chargeback.
The chargeback is filed: If the bank deems the claim valid, they file a chargeback with the card network (e.g., Visa, Mastercard).
The merchant is notified: The acquiring bank (merchant's bank) receives the chargeback notification and informs the merchant.
The merchant responds: The merchant can either accept the chargeback or contest it by providing evidence to support the transaction's validity.
The issuing bank makes a decision: Based on the evidence provided, the issuing bank decides whether to uphold or reverse the chargeback.
Possible arbitration: If the merchant disagrees with the decision, they can request arbitration from the card network, which makes a final ruling.
Throughout this process, strict timeframes must be adhered to by all parties. For merchants, it's crucial to act quickly when notified of a chargeback to maximize the chances of successfully contesting it if the claim is fraudulent.
What is Chargeback Fraud?
Chargeback fraud occurs when a consumer makes an online purchase with their own credit card and then requests a chargeback from the issuing bank after receiving the goods or services. This type of fraud exploits the chargeback system, which was originally designed to protect consumers from unauthorized transactions or merchant misconduct.
In cases of chargeback fraud, the customer intentionally or unintentionally misuses the chargeback process to obtain both the purchased item and a refund. This can happen for various reasons, including buyer's remorse, dissatisfaction with a product, or a deliberate attempt to defraud the merchant.
Chargeback fraud is particularly challenging for merchants because it's often difficult to distinguish from legitimate chargebacks. Unlike criminal fraud, where stolen credit card information is used, chargeback fraud involves transactions made by the actual cardholder. This makes detection and prevention more complex, as traditional fraud prevention measures may not be effective.
The impact of chargeback fraud extends beyond the immediate financial loss of the transaction. Merchants also face additional fees, potential damage to their reputation, and the risk of exceeding chargeback thresholds set by payment processors, which could lead to higher processing fees or even account termination.
Types of Chargeback Fraud
Chargeback fraud can manifest in various forms, each presenting unique challenges for merchants. Understanding these different types is crucial for developing effective prevention strategies.
Friendly Fraud
Friendly fraud occurs when a legitimate cardholder makes a purchase but later disputes the transaction with their bank, often claiming they didn’t authorize it or never received the product. This type of fraud is sometimes unintentional—such as when a customer forgets about a purchase or doesn’t recognize the charge on their statement. However, it can also be deliberate, with customers exploiting the chargeback system to get both the product and a refund.
Friendly fraud is particularly challenging for merchants because it involves legitimate transactions made by the actual cardholder, making it difficult to distinguish from genuine disputes. It accounts for a significant percentage of chargebacks and often results in financial losses, additional fees, and damage to a merchant’s reputation.
Criminal Fraud
Criminal fraud occurs when a fraudster uses stolen credit card information to make unauthorized purchases. Unlike friendly fraud, this type of chargeback fraud involves a third party who has no connection to the cardholder or merchant. Once the legitimate cardholder notices the unauthorized transaction, they file a chargeback with their bank to recover their funds.
Criminal fraud is especially prevalent in online transactions where merchants cannot physically verify the buyer’s identity. Fraudsters often target high-value items that can be quickly resold. For merchants, criminal fraud not only leads to chargebacks but also increases the need for advanced fraud-prevention tools to detect and block suspicious transactions.
Triangulation Fraud
Triangulation fraud is a more sophisticated form of chargeback fraud that involves three parties: the fraudster, an unsuspecting customer, and the merchant.
Here’s how it typically works:
The fraudster sets up a fake online store or listing offering goods at unusually low prices.
An unsuspecting customer places an order on the fake store and provides their payment information.
The fraudster uses stolen credit card details to purchase the item from a legitimate merchant and has it shipped directly to the customer.
When the legitimate cardholder notices the unauthorized transaction, they file a chargeback with their bank. The merchant ends up losing both the product and the payment, while the fraudster profits from scamming both the customer and the business.
Triangulation fraud is particularly damaging because it’s harder to trace back to its source, leaving merchants vulnerable to repeated attacks if they don’t implement strong preventative measures.
What Kinds of Businesses Are Affected by Chargeback Fraud?
Chargeback fraud affects a wide range of businesses, but some industries are more vulnerable than others due to the nature of their products or services. Here are the types of businesses most commonly impacted:
E-Commerce Stores: Online retailers are prime targets for chargeback fraud because they operate in a card-not-present (CNP) environment, where verifying the legitimacy of transactions is more challenging.
Subscription-Based Services: Companies offering recurring billing services, such as streaming platforms, SaaS providers, and meal kit deliveries, often face subscription fraud.
Travel and Hospitality: Airlines, hotels, and travel agencies frequently deal with chargebacks from customers disputing bookings or claiming dissatisfaction with services.
Luxury Retailers: High-value items like jewelry, electronics, and designer goods are attractive targets for fraudsters due to their resale value.
Food Delivery Services: Restaurants and delivery platforms often face disputes from customers claiming orders were incorrect or never delivered.
Event Ticket Sellers: Businesses selling tickets for concerts, sports events, or conferences may encounter chargebacks from customers who change their minds or claim non-delivery.
While these industries are particularly at risk, any business that accepts credit card payments can fall victim to chargeback fraud. Understanding the vulnerabilities specific to your industry is essential for implementing effective prevention measures.
How Does Chargeback Fraud Hurt Merchants?
Chargeback fraud has far-reaching consequences for merchants beyond the immediate loss of revenue. It impacts multiple aspects of a business’s operations and long-term sustainability.
Financial Losses
The most obvious impact of chargeback fraud is the direct financial loss. Merchants not only lose the revenue from disputed transactions but also incur additional fees imposed by payment processors. Mastercard estimates that merchants incur $15 to $70 in operational costs for every card dispute. Furthermore, if the merchant has already shipped a product, they lose both the item and its associated shipping costs.
Damage to Reputation
Chargeback fraud can tarnish a merchant's reputation among banks and payment processors. A high volume of chargebacks signals potential issues with customer satisfaction or fraud prevention measures. This could lead to increased scrutiny or even termination of merchant accounts. Additionally, dissatisfied customers who abuse chargebacks may leave negative reviews online, further damaging the business’s credibility.
Operational Costs
Handling chargebacks requires time and resources that could be better spent on growing the business. Merchants must investigate disputes, gather evidence, and communicate with payment processors—all of which can strain customer service teams and increase operational costs.
Increased Fraud-Prevention Costs
To combat chargeback fraud, merchants often invest in advanced fraud-prevention tools and technologies. While these measures are necessary, they add to operational expenses. Smaller businesses may struggle to afford robust systems, leaving them more vulnerable.
High Chargeback Ratios
Exceeding acceptable chargeback thresholds can result in penalties from payment processors or even account termination. This disrupts cash flow and forces merchants to find alternative payment solutions, which may come with higher fees or less favorable terms.
How To Prevent Chargeback Fraud
Preventing chargeback fraud requires a proactive approach that combines technology, customer service improvements, and clear policies. Here’s how merchants can reduce their risk:
Encourage Different Payment Methods
Offering alternative payment methods like open banking-based account-to-account (A2A) payments can reduce reliance on credit cards and minimize chargeback risks. Open banking enables direct transfers between bank accounts, bypassing traditional card networks and reducing opportunities for fraudulent disputes.
Improve Customer Service
Excellent customer service can prevent disputes from escalating into chargebacks. Ensure customers can easily reach your support team through multiple channels (e.g., phone, email, live chat). Address complaints promptly and offer refunds when appropriate to maintain trust and avoid unnecessary disputes.
Provide Clear Return And Refund Policies
Transparent return and refund policies help set customer expectations and reduce misunderstandings that lead to disputes. Display these policies prominently on your website and include them in order confirmation emails. Make the process simple for customers to follow.
Use Robust Fraud-Prevention Tools
Invest in advanced fraud-detection systems that analyze transaction data for suspicious activity. Tools like 3D Secure authentication and machine learning algorithms can help identify potential fraud before it occurs.
Maintain Records And Evidence
Keep detailed records of all transactions, including invoices, shipping confirmations, and customer communications. This documentation is invaluable when contesting fraudulent chargebacks.
How To Fight Back Against Chargeback Fraud
When faced with fraudulent chargebacks, merchants have options to dispute claims effectively:
Respond Promptly To Claims
Time is critical in the chargeback process. Merchants typically have 20–45 days to respond after being notified of a dispute. Act quickly to gather evidence and submit it within the required timeframe to increase your chances of winning the case.
Collect And Present Evidence
Compile all relevant documentation to support your case. This may include proof of delivery (e.g., tracking numbers), receipts, order confirmations, customer communication records, and any other evidence demonstrating that the transaction was legitimate.
Work With Banks And Payment Processors
Establish strong relationships with your acquiring bank and payment processor. They can provide guidance on best practices for preventing fraud and assist you in navigating the dispute process effectively.
Is Chargeback Fraud On The Rise?
Yes—chargeback fraud is increasing at an alarming rate as e-commerce continues to grow. Several factors contribute to this trend:
Rise In Online Shopping: The shift toward digital commerce has created more opportunities for card-not-present transactions—a common target for fraudsters.
Consumer Awareness Of Chargebacks: More consumers are becoming aware of how easy it is to file a chargeback claim through their banks.
Economic Pressures: Financial hardships may drive some individuals to exploit the system as a way to recover money spent on purchases.
Sophisticated Fraud Tactics: Fraudsters are continually developing new methods to exploit vulnerabilities in payment systems.
According to Mastercard, annual global chargeback volume could reach 337 million by 2026, a 42% increase over 2023 levels. For merchants, this underscores the importance of implementing robust prevention strategies now to mitigate future risks.
By staying informed about emerging trends and leveraging advanced tools, businesses can protect themselves against this growing threat while maintaining positive relationships with customers and payment processors alike.
Sources:
Mastercard - What is a Chargeback?
Mastercard - Chargeback Prevention
Sources last checked on: 31 January 2025
This publication is provided for general information purposes and does not constitute legal, tax or other professional advice from Ivy GmbH or its subsidiaries and its affiliates, and it is not intended as a substitute for obtaining advice from a financial advisor or any other professional. We make no representations, warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, that the content in the publication is accurate, complete or up to date.
